Saturday, December 12, 2020

Regarding the Supreme Court's decision on a lack of standing for TX et Al. to challenge election practices in other States:

Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 of the USC states that States may not "keep troops or ships of war..." or "engage in war".  When the States entered into Union with one another, they relinquished the right to settle differences by force of arms.  If a dispute arose on the execution of Federal law within another State, there was no recourse but appeal to the Government, which falls squarely in Article III, Section 2.  To state it clearly, States gave up this sovereign right with the promise that the Supreme Court would adjudicate disputes.

For a modern example, consider the Ukraine.  After the fall of the Soviet Union, the Ukraine was an independent sovereign nation, armed with Nuclear Weapons.  In exchange for relinquishing those weapons, the promise was made that the United States would guarantee its sovereignty and security.  So when a conflict did arise with the nuclear armed Russian neighbor, they had no recourse but to hope for relief and protection from the United States.  But after Russia annexed the Crimea, we did nothing.  So to with the Supreme Court; when an act of egregious violation of sovereignty occurs, the USC mandates that the only recourse and redress is through the Supreme Court.  When they reject a hearing on that dispute they have violated the promise made.  This is also not unlike the philosophy of Gun Control on a smaller scale:  if you turn in your weapons, the State will be your protection; until it isn't, and you find yourself at the mercy of corrupt and evil men.

That is the general reasoning that this case should have been heard.  But what of this specific case?  Is there really a "dispute" here between States, or is it just a disagreement about how one State chooses to resolve its own internal affairs?  There is in fact one, and only one, caveat to the manner in which States conduct their affairs, guaranteed and therefore mandated by the USC.  Article IV Section 4 states that "The United States shall guarantee to every state in this Union a republican form of government..."  Most States in this Union would not join together to be governed by a President if any or most of those States were governed by a Monarchy, or by a Socialist Dictatorship, or a Despotic Junta.

When a State begins acting by Executive Fiat, it is no longer a "republican form of government".  When it no longer requires legislative authority, it is no longer a republic.  When it stops following its own Constitution, it is most definitely no longer a republic.  The Constitution envisions that the State's government would be besieged from within by anti-republican forces, and would require rescue from without.  But it is equally the case that the State government itself becomes corrupt, and will not seek Federal relief for its own violations of that guaranteed form.

Therefore, in that the other States of the Union will not be joined in government with a despotic oligarchy that denies a republican form of government to its people, they have the absolute standing to call into question the results of any vote taken by those several states.

We all agreed to lay down our arms, to not fight the petty border skirmishes of Medieval European fiefdoms, and to let peaceful adjudications occur through a Supreme Court.  We all agreed to form republican style governments, governed by Constitutions that lent authority through the consent of the governed.  Both of these essential pillars have been attacked, and the injured victim is the general consent of the people of this nation and its several States to be governed in Union.

Saturday, February 13, 2016

Natural Born Citizens
February 13, 2016

Since Donald Trump is still pushing this line of attack, I think I'll weigh in with my two-cents.  For context, I dug into this issue pretty heavily during the '08 campaign.  I'm actually pretty frosted that it's come up again, after I tried and failed spectacularly at having a satisfactory engagement with anyone, from any side, on the merits for or against.  I was willing to be convinced, no matter what the consequence and effect on my personal desires.  So, in the absence of engagement in discussion when it mattered in '08, I've just had to figure it out for myself, and I'll state my findings, and position.  Also, to be fair to Donald Trump, he was virtually the only person in the public eye to not give up the "debate", until a copy of Obama's birth documents were posted (but he did not actually further the discussion of the salient points of the debate).

Here's a summary of the issue:  When the Constitution was written in 1787, a clause was added for the qualifications for holding the office of the President:  "No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President;"  There is no iron-clad definition of Natural Born Citizen in the Constitution or supporting documents, or this would not be an issue.  So, everyone's been left to scour antiquity for original intent, precedent, etc. 

I thought I had encountered a clue as to the original intent of this clause when, in 2010, Kenya adopted a new constitution.  It went something like this:  Under the Kenyan Constitution, Barack Obama was considered to be a natural born citizen of Kenya, since his father was Kenyan.  That is, he would be entitled to citizenship in Kenya; Kenya would not have to *decide* to admit him as a citizen, and he could be claimed to be a dual citizen of the United States and Kenya.  It struck me that perhaps the concept of the clause was to prevent any possibility of foreign allegiance of the President, and any entanglements such Dual Citizenship might cause.  This would argue for the Natural Born clause to be applied as "born of citizens who themselves were not dual citizens (and maybe even could not claim natural citizenship from another country), in the United States".  This would prevent any possibility of either the candidate or the foreign country from making a claim of citizenship.

I've rejected this theory, because it relies completely on a third party's determination about claims of citizenship.  For example, Britain could decide to extend natural citizenship to all descendants of it's former colonies, or some other strange thing.  The only thing that makes sense is to rely on a criteria not controlled by another country.

This invalidates Trump's claim about birth place as the sole criteria.  As I discovered with Obama, another country could still claim citizenship for you, for the most basic reason that one of your parent's was from that country.  The only thing that matters is whether or not you can claim to have been born a citizen of the United States, regardless of any other claims.

To that end, it is nonsensical to say that being born abroad instead of at home to a legitimate citizen of the united states *does not confer natural citizenship*.  When we travel to a foreign country, not a single person would assume that having a child while in that country would deny that child the automatic and natural rights of a citizen of our own country.  That would be as if to say that we cease to exist as citizens of the United States once we cross the virtual boundary of the country.

My conclusion then is that anyone born to a U.S. Citizen is a U.S. Citizen by birth.  The location of birth may also invoke arbitrary claims by other parties, but they are immaterial to the fact that that child is a Natural Born Citizen.  Furthermore, since it is a natural right, it cannot be undone by paper work, or lack of paper work.  We don't assume our natural rights (life, liberty, etc.) are only in effect because of a document, they are in effect *by nature*.  If your paperwork is not *in order* then it's a problem for the Bureaucracy, not for the natural citizen to whom the Bureaucracy must answer.

Monday, July 14, 2014

We continue to approach a point of irreconcilable differences.  This one is the reverse problem of federalism, when the laws of one state to another are so diametrically opposed that national continuity becomes a major issue.  Of course, the dramatic expansion of power from the Judiciary via the 14th ammendment should have at least fixed these kinds of situations.  According to that decision, a citizen of the United States has rights that are universal at the State level, as reaffirmed recenty by the Supreme Court.  So, you are permitted to own firearms as a federal citizen, no matter what State you live in, but apparently not in the manner you carry it.

This should at a minimum be a huge warning and caution for everyone buying firearms in states neighboring those with draconian gun laws, given at time of purchase.  There should also be some leeway built into NJ law for the obvious, inevitable, and predictable case of people accidentally crossing the invisible line of a State boundary.  Frankly, if this kind of thing stands, then we really ought to have immigration and customs checkpoints entering NJ to explain the rules of the State, or most common rules, etc (like California does with its Fruit inspection checkpoints).  Also, it would really drive home the atmosphere law abiding citizens live under in NJ.

And last but not least, it's also a good lesson in what you do and do not need to state to a police officer at a traffic stop.  He had no probable cause for inspecting her vehicle for a firearm, and she had no obligation to answer any questions about it.  Whether she had an obligation to offer it up morally is another Post.

http://www.my9nj.com/story/25996007/nj-gun-permit-problems

Monday, April 8, 2013

A Fundamental Divide: Innocent Until Proven Guilty

http://www.breitbart.com/Breitbart-TV/2013/04/06/MSNBC-Children-Are-Not-Yours-They-Belong-To-The-Community

This video gets at the root of a fundamental divide:  "innocent until proven guilty", or "guilty until proven innocent".  Your answer as to which philosophy you hold, and the degree to which you hold it, will greatly influence your political position.  Progressives seem to basically hold to the latter, as it applies to individuals, and to the former as it applies to government.  Conservatives hold to the former for individuals, and to the latter as it applies to government.

Friday, October 21, 2011

Libya, the Other Good War?

I must admit to being confused on several points about the “conclusion” of the Libyan conflict / war. In the first place, the confusion begins with what to call it. Since the Iraq conflict was labeled a War, it seems only right to label Libya a War as well.

The next point of confusion comes from my experiences in the early 2000’s, when I was brow beaten, and savaged, for daring to defend the President at that time, and his conduct of the Iraq War. At the time, Afghanistan was still considered a Good War, since Al Qaeda was directly acknowledged to be supported by the government there. I was told Iraq was secondary, and that there was no national interest, and that if we had stop every mad man dictator in the world we’d have to attack half the world’s countries, etc. But now it seems that for even less justification than was used for Iraq, we allowed, supported, and participated in the efforts to remove Qaddafi, dead or alive, from rule of Libya. Hilary Clinton says “we came, we saw, he died” with a smile on her face (put a cowboy hat on her, and she’d have a good likeness to the parody of George Bush, no?).

I also remember when Pat Robertson was condemned for suggesting that the way to deal with a South America Communist dictator involved possible assassination. But now have we not done precisely that in Libya? Are we not in fact going after the world’s bad actors, as it was painfully and exhaustively declaimed to me that we should not? But that’s the problem, isn’t it? Which leaders do we get to call bad actors and strong men? Which ones are deserving of death? The left complained when George Bush was making what they considered to be arbitrary judgments on this matter. But is it now okay to make those same arbitrary judgments with Obama at the helm?

I write this not to argue with the death of the mad man Qaddafi. I was in Liberia, and saw and heard first hand the destruction wrought by his meddling in the affairs of his continent (he financed and supplied many an insurrection in his day). Good riddance. But I cannot believe I am seeing this come from the same people who so vigorously attacked George Bush for essentially the same activity. If everyone is going to try to take credit here and say it is a good thing, then I want an apology (tongue in cheek), or at least an acknowledgement that there’s some serious soul searching that needs to be done in figuring out exactly what our role is in the world today, and the extent and use of our armed forces and diplomatic service in carrying that out.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

(Re) Building a PC (part II)

Video Cards

So, I bought a new video card. Why? Well, I never could get the drivers on the old card to work right with Vista. And after digging into it and fiddling around enough I decided hacking Vista to make it work wasn't worth the effort (and did I mention Civ5 is a real video hog?). Also, my backup computer (thanks cousin Keith!) turns out to have a PCI-express slot, so I can re-use my current card. No brainer, buy a new card, move the old one, done!

wait
(time passes)
wait
(time passes)
the sword from the junction appears in your hand!

Sorry, old Zork joke. So the new card arrives, and while I'm waiting an eternity for Vista to shutdown, I pop the side off my old computer. That's when I notice that the proprietary Dell configured 305 measly Watt power supply does not have any extra PCI-e power adapters! Darn, well, I'll pick up another supply later and suffer for now. Right, Vista finishes shutting down, so pull out the old card, and... That's when I notice the new card requires not ONE but TWO extra PCI-e power adapters! ...Aaaaaggghhhh!!!!

So, back to TigerDirect to pick up a new supply with two adapters, and because I'm in a bad mood I pick up a copy of Windows7, since it's the only thing that supports DirectX11, and if I don't use a DirectX11 video card with a DirectX11 OS, than what's the point, right? RIGHT?!?

(from the vault of the Idiot Build-it-yourself Computer Geeks)

Saturday, February 26, 2011

Quote of the Day

I'm not worried about the things I don't understand, these are confusing and someday I may understand them, or I may not. If I'm worried about anything, it's the things I think I understand, that tomorrow I may consider confusing. Fortunately, I have successfully arrived at the knowledge that nearly everything is confusing to me, and so I worry about very little.

Saturday, January 8, 2011

A Plan to Fix the Primaries

I'd like to propose a plan. I'm tired of have 9 conservatives and 1 moderate run in the primary, only to have the conservatives split the vote and the moderate get cross-over independents / democratic party votes and take all the delegates in a winner take all election. We can't have a separate primary, it would cost too much. And it's a little too much to ask the 9 conservatives to "do their duty" and just step aside for one to run (and we also wouldn't get a say in such a process, it'd be another smoke filled back room deal).

So, let's get the people we think are true conservatives to make a pact, and publicize it. For the first three Caucus / Primaries, Conservatives will vote only for these people, in a sort of parallel primary. Then, no matter what else is going on, the winner of that group will continue while the others drop out. In addition, that candidate will stay until the convention. If they win the convention, fine. If not, they will be the conservative voice there. What do you think?

Also, this applies to liberal / progressive voters as well. I'm sure they're just as sick of not having a voice at the conventions. I'll take comments from anyone!

Addendum: For clarification, this was originally in reference to the U.S. Federal Presidential election, but can apply to other elections as well.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

(Re) Building a PC

My Athlon XP computer recently quit working, and in lieu of buying a replacement computer, I decided to fix it. Why? Because it was the only computer that connected to my printer. Vista and beyond will not recognize it. Why don't I buy a new printer? Because the one I have works just fine, and it has a scanner and copier feature built in. So,

1. Diagnose the broken computer - computer periodically shuts off, and temperature monitor shows very hot CPU.

2. Open up computer, and use half a can of compressed air to blow out several years of dust. Take off CPU heat sink and fan. Discover half inch cake of dust between fan and heat sink. Well, there's my CPU temperature problem.

3. Put everything back together, and turn on. Works great, temperature nice and steady! Then randomly starts shutting off (which was why I stopped using the computer for a while a year or so ago).

4. Computer turns on and shuts off after 30 seconds or so, before even leaving BIOS, so suspect motherboard.

5. Look at capacitors on board. Sure enough, several are *popped* and rusty, so they need to be replaced. Are you kidding? I have a degree in electrical engineering, not electronic repair, I haven't soldered anything in years, just looked at a computer screen for a decade. Plus, finding the "right" capacitor looks to be impossible, as there are at least 20 options on digi-key for capacitor parameters. I was hoping to just boost some of a random piece of broken electronics in the garage. Plus, by the time I order new ones, de-solder the old ones (without a solder pump, or braid because that damages the board), and solder them back in without burning a hole in the board, I'll probably have spent as much time and effort as buying a new cheap board from the internet.

6. Go to find a cheap board, search for Socket A board on PriceWatch. Oh, cool, $25 for the first item listed! Buy it, and sit back and wait for the magic to happen.

7. The magic is, a trick, as it turns out. Board arrives, but it's *not* a Socket A board. I have no idea why it showed up in the Socket A search. Okay, fine, processors are cheap too. What socket is it? Hmmm, 754. Let's see, .... Hey, wait a minute, there don't seem to be *any* vendors except one sketchy looking website dealing in probably second hand chips for socket 754. Arghh!!

8. About this time, as I'm searching for all this on my Vista-non-printer-compliant-but-other-wise-decent-machine, it shuts off inexplicably.

9. Diagnose, take cover off. Blow out several years of dust with the second half of compressed air can.

10. ....

11. (sigh)

12. Heatsink falls right the heck off my board, just missing my video card, and lands out side the computer. The plastic nub that holds the 'sink onto the CPU has just snapped right off. I don't even know what to call the part, let alone find a new one. Oh, and I can't search for it, since my computer is now sans heat sink.

13. Set up *good* computer on its side and set heat sink on top of CPU, and declare no one is to touch the case. Get online, and finally find a "Heat sink retention bracket" for my socket type (AM2+ for those keeping track).

14. While going through this process, I finally answer another nagging question I had about the replacement motherboard I bought. There didn't seem to be any place to hook a heat sink on... Ah. Well, now I know I need a "heat sink retention bracket" for a 754 socket board. This turns out to be very difficult to find as well, but I locate one on e-bay, in England.

15. I also settle on a *new* Sempron 3100 chip for the re-build computer, which comes with fan, since I was also ch0king on finding, buying, and shipping a fan for the *new* CPU.

16. Get both retention brackets, and new socket 754 CPU w/ fan. Fix up *good* computer with new retention bracket so I can actually set it back up and use the DVD drive again, and not worry about the heat sink falling off.

17. Install retention bracket in old re-build computer (which by the way is a pain, since you have to take everything off and remove the mother board to screw in a back plate for it).

18. Install *new* CPU. Plug everything back in, and turn on.

19. Okay, what is that Horrible noise? I think this *new* CPU has been in its box for about a decade, and the fan sounds like its bearings (I didn't think CPU fans *had* bearings) are about to fail.

20. BIOS comes up. Gateway. Gateway? Did I just see *Gateway* on my Bios? I have a good feeling some one ripped this board out of some office computer being tossed in the junk.

21. Nothing else happening. Oh, okay, forgot to plug the hard drive back in. Restart.

22. Yay! Windows XP boot screen. And it says: "You need to activate this copy of Windows." Darn it , I forgot Windows freaks out when you change the hardware, it thinks I've pirated the OS. And the wireless USB mouse doesn't work until I install all the right drivers. And the Fan is STILL really loud!

I'm SO glad I decided to repair my computer.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

To Luke Lucier, A letter I’ll never get to send,

So many memories, so many experiences. I’ll remember them always.

Luke and his brother Joe were a big part of growing up, in my homes at Billerica, Massachusetts and then Newport, New Hampshire, and at their home in Brockton, Massachusetts. We got into loads of trouble together, they and I and my brother Jesse. But we explored, and we had adventures, those absolutely pure adventures that only children can have. Our imaginations on full, and feeding off each other, we found places and things that would never exist to anyone but ourselves. And those shared experiences would stick with us forever.

At the beach, we explored the tidal marshes. We trekked through the mud on our makeshift rafts, through unknown, impenetrable water, daring each other to push farther upstream, while fighting the fears from ourselves and the others. We pushed out to sea, and imagined voracious lovecraftian monsters in the deep, waiting to grab us from below.

At their house in Brockton, we stayed up insanely late, playing Nintendo games. Super Mario Brothers was burned in our eyes, till their parents made us go to bed. We played thirty-one at the kitchen table, us kids with matchsticks and the adults with quarters. Cable TV was just in vogue, and we watched the penultimate action movies of our age, Predator and Aliens, over and over again till we could recite them line for line.

Luke and Joe had turned their backyard into a gigantic jungle gymnasium. They were experts at the make-shift obstacle course, and I get tired even now thinking about them swinging through the equipment.

We explored the back alleys by their house, and got caught once scrambling over a random chain-link fence. Luke showed his characteristic street sense and bolted, but I as usual followed the guy’s order to stop and come back to him, despite not knowing who or what he was. Turned out to be the janitor of the school next door, so I got an escort through to the front door of the school, no harm no foul!

At night we became Ninja, and dressed the part as we could. We explored the roof tops in the city, and walked the roof line at our house in New Hampshire. Our house had a barn and a third story attic, and a connecting room in between. Our parents were entertaining people downstairs, and had left us to our own devices. On came the black clothes and swords (my brother had picked up a katana from a trip to Germany), and our band of stealthy assassins set off across the roof line from the house to the barn. Of course, real ninjas wouldn’t have let themselves be lit up against the sky line behind, and a call to the police by the neighbors ended our escapade (after we had made our journey!).

Our imagination fueled, super powered alter egos really took off in the lakes of New Hampshire. We stayed at a house on Lake Sunapee for two weeks one summer, and the lake became ours. Luke’s dad took us out on the Motor boat, and we cruised the lake in style, unstoppable. Luke was ever the ladies man, and hatched a plan to travel back across the lake at night, to find a girl we saw but briefly on boat passed by that day. Somehow we thought better of the idea, but with Luke and Joe around, things like that actually felt possible.

They brought the most amazing fireworks with them to the house, as we were there over the Independence Day weekend. We lit off a string of Chinese firecrackers so long and so loud that we were never invited back again, and we’d never want to go back, because you’d never be able to recreate or top those two weeks again.

We camped at millers pond, and paddled a canoe out to the middle of the small lake, singing our lungs out as loud as we liked, no one around for miles to hear us. We sang silly songs that you’d only sing around good friends, and that only were funny because we were already laughing at each other so hard. We dreamed of how funny it would be one day to all be old and gray, and paddle back out to the middle of that lake, and laugh with each other again about all the good times past.

We’ll never get that chance to all be together again, on this earth. God willing we’ll all meet again in heaven, and maybe there will be a lake somewhere where we’ll all be able to gather as friends once more.

I’ll miss you Luke, I can still see your eyes and your smile, I’ll never forget your laugh, and you and your brother having your classic epic brother fights! I’ll never forget going to see DC Talk with you, and listening to bootlegged rap music cassettes. I’ll never forget that day we went to an amusement park with that youth group one year. We went off by ourselves for almost the entire day, and rode so many rides we both finally threw up, which had never happened to me before, and I've been motion sick at amusement parks ever since! I remember we were so hungry that afternoon, we got food from one of the booths, I remember it was Ribs, and they were the best, best Ribs we’d ever had, and the best I’d ever had since. We conquered that place, the most fun I’d ever had at an amusement park.

I’ll never forget taking turns mowing the lawn at our house in Newport, to work up a sweat, so when we got to Pollard’s Mills swimming hole it wouldn’t feel so cold. We rode our bikes all across town, to Pollard’s Mills, and down the side streets and through the woods at night. The town was our playground, like any place we were all together at. I’ll never forget playing war games with squirt guns through the local cemetery (hey, most of the people buried there were my ancestors!), and then when the cops stopped us with no less than three squad cars.

I’ll never forget you man. Rest in peace Luke Lucier. God be with you Joe, and Ruth, and Sky, and Eddie, my belated and sincerest condolences.

Your friend, Benjamin Claggett

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Building Bridges?

So, someone I consider to be a good friend just deleted me on Face Book. Not hid me, deleted me. I can't even reply to her now, because that was my only connection. Why did she delete me? Because she's a bridge builder, or so she says. Funny, I didn't think you built bridges with a torch in hand.

She didn't like my article about Natural Born Citizens, and how I came to the conclusion that the founders intended the Constitution to only allow people born of two American citizens to become President. Thought I was Xenophobic or something, because I thought it made sense that the possibility of being a dual citizen in charge of the nation's armed forces could be a reasonable conflict of interest. But no, she's an enlightened intellectual, and couldn't be bothered to actually deal with me on my well reasoned position. So instead of being honest with me, she just deleted me. As I say, funny way to build a bridge.

You see, I've been thinking a lot about building bridges lately. So here are some observations: first, you don't need to build bridges to people you agree with, you're already on the same side! So, when you're building a bridge you are only ever doing so with people you disagree with. Secondly, bridges must be built from both sides. You can build your bridge to the middle, but if one is not built in return, you'll never connect. Third, and most importantly, you have to be able to see your bridge "from the other side." Otherwise, you won't be able to build your bridge in the right direction.

That's all well and good fanciful fluff, but how about some more practical knowledge. Try this: the other person is always right. How's that you say? You're finally embracing post-modern nihilism? Hardly. What I mean is, the other person thinks they are right, just as you think you are right, and so you must treat them as such. That is, you must respect that they believe they are right, and act accordingly. No one will build a bridge back to you if they do not feel respected.

So, assuming she ever reads this, let me try applying these pearls of wisdom to the situation at hand. Case 1, I write a heartfelt and carefully considered piece detailing a nugget of knowledge I have recently gained, and I share it honestly and excitedly with my friends, and ask for and receive honest feedback (mostly negative, but honest) on my opinion and idea. I felt respected that other people considered my idea as something I was interested in, even though they disagreed. I felt respected that they were willing to share their disagreement with me. It was hard work, pushing past those disagreements to share honestly with them, and for them to respond in kind. We didn't change each other's minds. But we built a bridge!!! I now trust them a little more, and they trust me.

Except for my friend. She was offended by my piece, but she wouldn't tell me so. But I believe she was offended. That is, whether or not I think the offense was legitimate, she believed it so, and therefore it most certainly was, to her at the least. And when you're building bridges, that's all that matters! And so if you ever read this, know that I did not intend to offend, if you can accept that. Know that I accept you were offended, and I only wish you had trusted me enough to tell me so. I also wish that you had given me the trust to recognize that I honestly believed in my work. You cannot build bridges any other way, and it takes the sting out of the offense to be molded in this way. To know someone is honestly committed to an idea that you find offensive can give you the strength to hold that connection, but it still takes work and you must continually try at it.

Case 2. A current event initiated by a group of people has our family in a stir. This group has caused offense, yet they and their supporters refuse to recognize the offense. They do not wish to build a bridge, or give the offended the respect of holding honest feelings of offense. A writer pens an article detailing exactly where the offense comes from, in an effort to enlighten those who do not understand the source of the grief. My wife posts said article on *her own* wall. Our friend reads and takes her own offense at the article. But instead of respecting that my wife indeed holds these things honestly and openly, and reacting as such, she blatantly insinuates she is a bigot. After my wife, who has had it with being slandered as a racist, bigot, etc., without so much as a single shred of evidence, lets our friend know that she's had it with being slandered as a racist, bigot, etc., without so much as a shred of evidence, our friend the bridge builder deletes us from her friends list.

Was she honestly offended by the article in question? I believe so. Was she justified in insinuating my wife is a bigot? Maybe she honestly believes it to be so, but she did not respect her enough to say so honestly to her face. "But you know so much about building bridges, why couldn't you build one with her?" you say. Ah, but remember it takes two to build a bridge.

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Natural Born Citizen

The waters on this issue have become so muddied with “Birthers” and myriad claims of dubious (and not so dubious) natures that even discussing this rationally has become difficult. It is so emotionally charged that considering the issues involved and not the implications has become impossible, rather like a tainted jury pool. However, I will attempt to lay out the facts as I see them one more time, with the addition of a new wrinkle from current events.

From all available information, our President, Barack Obama, is a Citizen of the United States of America. However, he is not a Natural Born Citizen, but rather a Naturalized Citizen of the United States. A Natural Born Citizen must be born of two Citizens of the United States (who, themselves, do not have to be Natural Born). A Naturalized Citizen may be granted citizenship under a variety of circumstances, and in the case of our President, he was Naturalized by fact of one of his parents being a Natural Born Citizen (his mother).

However, since his other parent was a Natural Born Citizen of Kenya, he (Barack) could not therefore be a Natural Born Citizen of the United States. Only just today, August 5, 2010, the nation of Kenya ratified a new Constitution. This new Constitution grants citizenship to anyone who is or has been born of at least one parent who is a Citizen of Kenya. Therefore, our President is automatically a dual citizen with citizenship in Kenya as well as the United States.

Finally, the United States Constitution retains a clause that requires Natural Born Citizenship for Presidential eligibility. The intent was to prevent individuals with divided allegiances from taking power of the executive branch of the country. Surely someone with dual citizenship is precisely the case these gentlemen were considering when they wrote this clause. That is, any Naturalized Citizen would have at least the possibility of claiming citizenship in another country, and thus divide his or her loyalty accordingly, whereas a Natural Born Citizen would have (at the least) none of the entanglements of dual citizenship and the burden of the inherent loyalties therein.

If I had to conjecture, I would say that they (the Founders) had in mind the bewildering array of entanglements existing within the European Continent at the time. The intermarriage among the ruling classes of the different nations caused a nightmarish maze of loyalties and duties and alliances that I believe the American Colonists wished to avoid in their new country.

Given the above, what are the implications to us now? Well, they range from the inane, to the bizarre, to the quite serious. In the matter of trivia, Barack Obama is the first openly publicized Naturalized Citizen to become President (the actual first would have been Chester Arthur, whose father was Irish and who may have been born in Canada). In a bizarre twist, the People of Kenya could now levy requirements on our President, to fulfill the duties of a Citizen of Kenya, unless he actually revoked his Citizenship (which would then prove he was indeed a dual citizen!). Aside from strange legal entanglements, it is quite apparent that Mr. Obama indeed has two home countries to contend with. We may never know the extent to which he is ultimately loyal to one or the other, as it is a matter of the unseen heart (he may not know himself!), which I think is why our Founders wished to spare us the trouble.

Finally, there is the most obvious and glaring point, which is that his election as President was not in fact Constitutional. Rather, his candidacy was deemed to be Constitutional by one federally appointed authority (the Chief Justice), his main opponent in the contest (John McCain), and a majority of the country (53% of the voting public). However, he was not deemed so in the correct fashion under the Constitution that he has sworn to uphold, namely the consent of three fourths of the states by Constitutional amendment. What does all that mean? Not much, just add it to the list of the many items our Government has deemed by its own standard to be legal when they are clearly not. But when will the camel’s back break? When will the list become so onerous that the Constitutional authority of our Government ceases, and only the authority of Force remains? This is the thing that we ought to be concerned about most of all in this strange affair.

Monday, March 22, 2010

No We Couldn't

Couldn't what? Keep it. Keep what? A Republic. We couldn't keep the Republic. Maybe we can restore it, maybe we can re-found it, but we couldn't keep it. Two Hundred and twenty three years ago a lady asked Benjamin Franklin at the close of the Constitutional Convention: “Well, Doctor, what have we got—a Republic or a Monarchy?”, and Franklin replied: “A Republic, if you can keep it.” The lady got her answer that day, and now we have Franklin's answer for him.

Our founders always knew this day would come. They prayed it would not, and there were many miracles along the way, and many days of blood and pain to preserve it. But battered and bruised it kept on. Until today. Today we have lost the Republic, if only temporarily. Today the Republic gave in to the pull of Socialism, and betrayed all its principles to do so. Today, the agreement between the sovereign States of America has been broken.

Always before, the agreement, the Constitution that bound the country and created a voluntary union of the separate states, had held, even if bent beyond recognition at times. Now the agreement has been flagrantly violated, and the "political bands which have connected them with another" have been dissolved, in spirit if not yet by law.

And so by law the Republic will continue to appear to function, to push forward. But the heart has been shattered, and the blood will eventually stop flowing through its veins. The heart was the American Spirit of people willing to do Good in a country that asked it of itself, but never forced that Good upon itself or others; of people willingly binding themselves to laws that punished only the commitment of Evil upon one another.

But no more. Now the willing spirit has been shackled like a slave. To representatives charged with protecting our way of life, it is no longer enough to merely punish Evil acts. Now the version of Good as seen by some must be forced to become the Good done by all in the country. Now, if your Good acts are not as some see Good, you have become Evil, and must be punished. Now, you cannot do Good willingly. Now you are compelled to do what some call Good; and in the subjugation to the Good will of some, we are all made slaves. Now, our reward for our willingness to do Good has been lost. We are forced to do what we do not believe is Good, and the Good we do has been forced from us, making all our gifts and generosity into mere obligation.

1"Be careful not to do your 'acts of righteousness' before men, to be seen by them. If you do, you will have no reward from your Father in heaven.

2"So when you give to the needy, do not announce it with trumpets, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and on the streets, to be honored by men. I tell you the truth, they have received their reward in full. 3But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, 4so that your giving may be in secret. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you." Matthew 6:1-4


Now, we can no longer do Good in the name we choose. Now our Good is done for us in the name of our representatives, chosen by some but not all, and we have again lost our reward.

This Republic has struggled over what was Evil, and what was to be punished as Evil by the Republic. Never have we struggled so hard over what was Good, and never has Good been punished as Evil by the Republic like today. Our Republic should and can deal with two groups of people who wish to do Good in their own way. And when those groups disagree, it has provided us with a way to establish a new agreement, if agreeable to most all, and if not, to allow us to continue doing Good in our own ways.

But now one group's Good has become the other group's Evil. Now instead of two groups doing Good in their own way, one group's Good of Socialism and Social Justice has been forced on the other, and the other group's Good of Economic Liberty and Personal Responsibility is a punishable Evil. And now we have proven that the two Goods will not mix, not even in our Republic that fought so hard, and bled so much so that they might.

"And just as you saw the iron mixed with baked clay, so the people will be a mixture and will not remain united, any more than iron mixes with clay." Daniel 2:43

And now we go about the business of disuniting, in spirit if not in law. As long as the one side compels the other, we may never disunite by law. But as long as we are compelled, we will never be the Republic of the United States of America again.

Sincerely, in peaceful melancholy and yet in hope of the return of my Lord Jesus,

Benjamin Passler Claggett
A Citizen and a Christian

Written this day, the Twenty Second of March, in the Year of Our Lord Jesus Christ Two Thousand and Ten

Friday, January 1, 2010

The One-Fourth Rule Amendment

A proposed amendment to the United States Constitution:

"Whereas a three-fourths majority of States (Legislatures or Conventions) are required to amend the United States Constitution, and by inference a more than one-fourth minority of States may block such an amendment,

So shall a greater than one-fourth minority of States (Legislatures or Conventions), who support an amendment preventing a change to the United States Constitution, have such an amendment be passed as binding upon the United States Constitution."

Such an amendment, a "one-fourth +1 amendment," will clarify the limits of government power beyond what is set forth in the United States Constitution, and demarcate which "three-fourths amendment" would be required to allow government the use of said powers.

In truth, the Bill of Rights ought to have been of this "one-fourth + 1" nature. That is, it should have only required a slightly greater than one-fourth minority of population to maintain the access to the rights therein. As it is now, when those rights are infringed on, it has now been established that we in fact need a three-fourths majority of the population to defend those infringements.

Addendum:
Another way to word or structure this amendment would be that 1/4th + 1 states could vote to overturn any congressional law as being unconstitutional. This would be a more "re-active" approach, whereas the former would be more "pro-active."

Sunday, December 27, 2009

Health Reform Constitutional?

http://www.theweek.com/bullpen/column/104493/Health_reform_Unwise_not_unconstitutional

Fortunately, David Frum does not decide what is and is not Constitutional. And neither does the Supreme Court. For something to be "Constitutional" it must be something that *I* agree should be in the purview of the federal government. That is the only standard of Constitutionality, and no one can tell me something is Constitutional when I believe it is not. What I decide to do about the circumstance (namely that the Federal Government agrees amongst itself that my personal health care / insurance / banking / transportation etc. falls under their jurisdiction) is an entirely different subject.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Statement of Faith (a work in progress, but a good start)

I believe that the people, places, and events of the Bible are real. I have read the accounts of those people, and believe that the God they spoke of is real, including all that he said and did, and promised to do. I believe the accounts spoken and written down about the man Jesus, who was called the Christ, the Messiah. I believe that the claims he made of himself were true, that he is the Son of God, who was and is and is to come. I believe that he was slain in my place, that he was executed for my transgressions. I believe the account of those who saw him raised from the dead, in physical form that they could touch, feel, and talk to. I believe that just as he was raised from the dead, so I will have new life through my faith in him. I believe this new and eternal life is a gift, freely given, and is not from any worthiness on my part. I believe I do not deserve it, and that no one does. But I believe it was offered freely, and I have freely accepted it, in faith.

I believe that humanity has been holding the burning coal of the knowledge of Good and Evil in its hands, ever since Adam and Eve ate of the fruit of the tree of the same. I believe all of our struggles as humans stem entirely from that event, and everything we do can be cast in the light of our attempts as humans to deal with that knowledge, whether to bury it, to put it back, to try and absorb it unto ourselves, to try to pass it on to get rid of it or at least share the burning pain, or to just wither under it. I believe the only way to deal with this knowledge and its resulting condemnation of ourselves is to ask for forgiveness from the God who made us, and accept his offered sacrifice of his only begotten Son, Jesus the Messiah, to account for that condemnation.

I believe heaven will be literally greater than I can possibly imagine. I believe that I will be counted worthy of entering into God's glory there, not from my own merit but from him whose blood covers my iniquity.

I believe when Jesus said on the cross that it was finished, I believe he meant it. I believe that the Gospel, the good news of human salvation and restoration to God through the death and resurrection of Jesus was complete and perfect the day the curtain to the Holy of Holies was ripped, and when he walked out of the tomb on the third day. I believe that our attempts to enhance and improve upon the Gospel are far more likely to be a regression back to the pagan heritage of our culture, than to be progressive advances in our spiritual maturity.

Therefore, I believe that our civilization is not advancing to a Utopian climax, but is only reflecting the seeds of its character, in proportion to its size. As humanity grows, so we see the fruits of those seeds clearer, but their character has not changed. I believe that at the right moment, God will remove the good fruit from the earth, and destroy what is left. I believe that this judgement is for God to perform, and not our place as humans, in this age, except within ourselves against the evil fruit in our own lives. Yet, I believe that wherever possible, and with whatever strength is given to us, we should defend those around us from the evil of this world.

I believe that Israel has been reconstituted according to God's will and is fulfilling the Biblical prophecies made about that nation. I believe that the Biblically prophesied war of Gog and Magog may happen within my lifetime, and that the nations and alliances of that war are almost all nearly in place. I believe that my country, the United States of America, has created a government founded on Biblical principles in a way unlike any other in history since the ancient nation of Israel, and like that nation it will not achieve the perfection it seeks until Christ reigns on the throne.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Meta-physics Model for a World without Time

It has been posited that our universe is actually only one of an infinite number of universes comprising the Multi-Verse, in which every possible state of being is captured.

I would like to posit that these are not disconnected universes, but rather form a single matrix of static 'verses, which in and of themselves do not change. There is in fact no dimension of Time at all. Rather, what we experience as time is actually the sequential movement through an infinite series of Universes, each with a different static state, much like a finite state machine. In my model, this "Infinite State Machine" has inputs for the current state of the Universe, and our "free-will" inputs as the remaining inputs, which the infinite state machine (again, in my model, God or his Creation) then uses to point to a new Universe.

God controls the frequency at which the states are traversed, and therefore our "Time" has almost no meaning to God. A thousand years are as a day. Also, we are not just occupying a single Universe, but rather are connected to every Universe, or possibly only a theoretical connection to infinite universes, since really only one universe would need to exist at any given time.

*Speculation* (as opposed to the previous iron clad mathematical proofs)
Perhaps, with this model, we would see the results of the famous quantum physics experiment, whereby a single "interfering" molecule stream behaves as a continuous wave, since a discrete stream of particles taken at subsequent states would appear to be a continuous stream. That is, the previous state *for that stream* was the previous particle issued, and so subsequent discrete particles interfere with the previously issued particle, creating the impression of a continuous stream.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Health Care Debate - Some Thoughts

Firstly, it has been posited that a private Insurance company is only in it for the money, and therefore will not have your best interests at heart. I would like to point out that the if a private company is just in it for the money, then the gov't is just in it for the power! Frankly, I'd rather be broke from an Insurance company sucking down my pocket book and still be free, than to have cheap health care, some extra money in my pocket, but be a slave to the gov't. And then have the gov't tax that extra money in my pocket so then I'm still broke.

Secondly, Insurance Companies do not have a problem of Capitalism (which is implied by them only being in it for the money), if anything they have a problem of Socialism. They are tasked with distributing money pooled together by a group of people, and trying to make sure they have enough left to make it worth their while. If they couldn't, they'd be doing something else more productive with their time! So, why would gov't, who would essentially be doing the same job, distributing pooled money out to people, be any better? Just because they won't keep any extra for a profit? They still have to pay all the people to do the work, and have you seen the gov't union retirement / benefits plan? Not cheap. But hey, if you don't think your insurance company shouldn't be making a profit, then fire them! Get someone else, or start your own! You can't do that with the gov't. Actually, a bunch of people have already started their own non-profit co-op insurance companies. Why not use them?

Thirdly, the Gov't doesn't magically change the amount of money available out there for all these health services. The only thing it has is an ability to borrow astronomical sums of money because of the guaranteed revenue stream from us, the tax payer. If you think that borrowing money to pay for increased health care for an entire nation in perpetuity is wise, then maybe we should also try filling the Sahara desert with water from a Dixie cup, which would be about as effective.

All gov't can do is redistribute the money differently. If you think its more equitable to have a "company" that you can't fire and compels you to use it making all your health choices, then I ask you, why can't we at least leave it to the State Gov'ts?

For my next post: "Why For-Profit ventures are better than Not-For-Profit ventures"

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

The Paradox of Freedom: Part I

The PROBLEM as I see it: We find our selves as a country wrestling with a conundrum, a living hypocrisy that is eating away at our body politic. That is, our country has been founded on the notion that there are some things that we as a collective society of individuals must agree to do together, in order to maintain our status as individuals. And therein lies the problem. Having accepted the premise that there are some things in which we must work together on (and hence sacrifice our sense of individuality), it now becomes difficult to argue which other things we must not be required to work together on.

Put another way, our founders decided that a nation of individuals, being a most high ideal, could not be obtained by those individuals remaining completely such. That is, for an instant in time they were indeed individuals, complete and sovereign (politically), owing no allegiance to anyone but themselves. But immediately after that moment they began to choose to join in compact with other sovereign individuals, for the purpose of defending against those that would remove their individuality.

But was this a bargain with the devil? When the first colonial said to the second colonial, "let's take up arms together, so that we may protect ourselves. We'll stand back to back so that no one may sneak up on us," was that the end of their lives as pure individuals? Or was the choice they made as individuals the very validation of themselves? After all, they chose to join together, and no one else made them to do so. And when a thief did sneak up and was shot by the colonials, did not they preserve themselves, to go on making choices?

"The freedom you enjoy, is the freedom enjoyed by others to use against you," they reason to themselves, after all while they walked where they would, so could the thieves! "But the freedom you sacrifice is the freedom sacrificed of others that they can no longer use against you," they reason further, and decide they have done a good thing. After they were joined, they could only walk where the other desired and vice-versa, but the thieves were denied walking behind the one or the other now.

Of course, the real question is can you make a choice to have no more choices? Can the first colonist choose to be joined forever to the second colonist? And is it really a choice if you cannot return from it?

Let us suppose that the colonists find themselves among many other like minded individuals, so many that the use of them all for a defense requires an overseer to coordinate the project. The overseer is chosen by a means agreed to by all the individuals, and performs his function of coordinating the defense of the group of individuals. The overseer then decides to coordinate the building of a wall around their dwellings, which the overseer says is also arguably for the defense of the group. The overseer then coordinates the building of public sewer systems within the walls, in case of prolonged siege, again for the defense of the group. Hospitals follow, along with safety regulations and management regimes, to ensure the group's resources are properly used, and that everyone is well fed and healthy to be ready for action "in defense of the group."

Soon the overseer has taken charge of every aspect of every individual action the "individuals" of the group might make. Many of the more trivial actions are permitted, such as which street to walk down, but the extent of those actions is approved by the overseer and documented in the group's laws. Did the individuals desire this outcome? The original purpose of appointing an overseer was so that they could conduct their individual affairs more freely by denying those who would seek to control and conquer them a divided and easy target. But in the end result, they have become precisely what they sought to avoid.

The first colonial decides, after reviewing the affair, that he would rather be shot in the back by a thief and at least have the freedom to walk where he liked without the by-your-leave of the overseer. After all, he reasons, "it is better to die trying to live free than to live as a slave forever. Perhaps I'll invite the second colonial as well, and we can go on protecting each others backs again as we used to."

The overseer cannot find anything in the book of the group's laws that say that "individuals" are allowed to leave the group. In fact, on closer inspection, the overseer cannot find anything about individuals at all any more, as everything has come under the purview of "the defense of the group" which does not contain the sense of individuals any longer. In fact, anyone who does not recognize themselves as being part of the group is then jailed for not contributing taxes for the "defense of the group."

The second colonial gives up and works within the group, since he'd rather have the illusion of freedom than to be jailed and have no sense of freedom at all, although he'd still rather walk freely and risk being shot by a thief, given the chance. The first colonial tries to make a run for it, but he finds there is no where to run to. The walls of the group have extended to the very sea itself. So the colonial decides to start over again right where he is, and is promptly arrested for non-payment of taxes, and thrown into jail.

While he sits in jail, he contemplates the paradox that has brought him and his follow colonials to this point. Namely, that they agreed to have any of their liberty as individuals taken away, in order that they might preserve their status as individuals, and thus eventually had all of their liberty taken away, and became individuals no longer! He reckons this in two ways: By the first reckoning, when some amount of liberty was removed, he was protecting the latter half. But by this reckoning, it implied there was a happy balance of liberty lost to liberty gained. Why, he could even lose up to half of his liberty to protect the other half and still come out even in the end! But was it possible to have a happy medium? Is not a single shackle just as constricting as ten shackles?

And so he tries to reckon a second way. How does a shackle not become a shackle? When you have the key, of course! In fact, forget the shackle, and turn those agreements into ropes, ones that we hold on to, and more importantly can let go of any time we would like. In fact, the only shackle he wishes to have any longer, is the one that will prevent all others from taking hold. The only agreement he wishes to make is the one whereby he will always be able to "let go" of the rope. And therefore the only agreement of freedom without paradox is ironically to agree to be able to break an agreement.

"But surely this is Anarchy, is it not?" says the colonial to himself. Ah, but then he considers that the freedom to break an agreement is also the freedom to make agreement anew. The freedom to make and break agreements is not a statement of Anarchy, it is only a means to either Order or Anarchy, as seen fit by the individual. "Wherever agreements breakdown into Anarchy, individuals may choose to make new agreements to bring Order to Chaos." Or so his thinking goes, as he ponders the paradox that is the basis of the government of his world.

Saturday, April 25, 2009

Term Limits

A lot of talk has been bandied about lately, either through the Tea Party movement or other forums, about imposing Term Limits on congressional representatives and senators.  It's not that I think this is a bad idea per say, but rather that there are unintended consequences.  It is not a cure-all, not even close, and may be worse than what we have now.

First of all, from a philosophical viewpoint, what are Term Limits?  They're a limit on the people that are being represented.  "But wait," you say, "isn't it a limit on the candidate?"  Currently, the people have the right to vote out the candidate every two years, no restrictions.  If you put term limits in, you've limited the right of the people to choose who they want to represent them.  What we're really saying with Term Limits is that we don't like who the people have chosen, or we think the people are too stupid to figure it out, and therefore we need to limit the damage the people can cause to themselves by kicking the representatives out for them.  

That doesn't sound like representative republican democracy.  It sounds like people trying to escape the accountability, that democracy demands, of the people for whom they elect (which I argue is one of the defining reasons for any democratic system).  This is not "Conservative" in my view.  Conservatives don't believe we need Government to protect ourselves from our own stupidity.  We only really need to protect ourselves from the stupidity of Government.  We'll deal with our own stupidity on our own, and with whoever we can convince to help us!

Second of all, we have right now people like John McCain, who have been in politics forever, who can't even get the point of entry of the 9/11 terrorists correct.  And these people are supposed to have experience.  Fine you say, let's kick them out, since experience means nothing.  But who will these new senators and congressmen rely on for the information to make their way through congress?  Will they not have Career, Life Long, Washington Insider staffers to grease the gears?  If so, we are now not just stuck with an incompetent life-long politician, who we can at least vote out of office, we are now stuck with scores of staffers who we can't vote out, and who will end up running our government.

I know, they probably Are running it right now.  But I guess that's my point.  Term limits will not change that fact, and may make it more of a fact.  And, they will limit our own choice.  There really is no solution to the "Staffer" problem.  We can only vote for and hold accountable politicians who are going to rely on good people, people that we can trust to serve the interest of those they represent.  Anything else would be unfairly limiting the representatives, telling them who they can and can't get help from (say, with term limits for staffers).

Of course, one change we might make is to get rid of the congressionally provided money they are allowed to hire staffers, but the unintended consequences are still there.  The richest representatives would drown the others in staffers hired from their own pockets (do they do this now?  Not sure, but probably), and overwhelm the congress with process and procedure.

No, the only real recourse is to reduce the power of the National Government (per Mark Steyn, "'federal' doesn't seem the quite the word anymore") to limit the damage career politicians can have.  And learn from our mistakes and vote in citizen legislators who won't be run over by career staffers.  To that end, I think it was mistake (and a massive power grab) for us to limit the size of congress.  As we grow ever larger, the portion of repesentation grows ever larger with it, till a citizen legislator just doesn't feel right in such an August Esteemed Body.  If they were still held to 1:30,000, we might actually know who our representative was without them having to have a major scandal to get on the news.